Labour’s vegan shadow environment secretary Kerry McCarthy has suggested that fishermen ought to be referred to as ‘fishers’, to render the description gender neutral.
She floated the suggestion on Twitter, musing “Shouldn’t say ‘fishermen’, but ‘fishers’ sounds wrong as gender neutral alternative?” The tweet received a mixed response.
Shouldn’t say fishermen but “fishers” sounds wrong as a gender neutral alternative?
— Kerry McCarthy (@KerryMP) November 27, 2015
Fellow Twitter-user and former Tory MP Louise Mensch enquired whether, as a vegan, McCarthy should be encouraging “fisherfolk” at all:
.@KerryMP Surely as a vegan you are against all fisherfolk and their livelihoods #LabourFishing #VoteConservative #HadYourFishnChips — Louise Mensch (@LouiseMensch) November 27, 2015
Other twitter users have helpfully come up with alternative gender neutral titles, some of which McCarthy pondered:
@NelFormaldehyde @KerryMP Demersal & Pelagic Retrieval Operatives. *Don’t want to lump deep sea & surface fish together.
— Ali L (@Alichat66) November 27, 2015
@GabrielScally I considered that but it sounds terribly twee — Kerry McCarthy (@KerryMP) November 27, 2015
@Broadbeak that sort of works… although implies people who live in that community rather than just those who do the job?
— Kerry McCarthy (@KerryMP) November 27, 2015
@arryTuttle @Broadbeak I’ll try that one out on them this morning – I think they might like it! — Kerry McCarthy (@KerryMP) November 27, 2015
@KerryMP @rileyjcox surely, these days, that should be fishercismen. Y’know, just to keep the precious uni darlings in their safe spaces.
— Dave Dorn (@Hifistud) November 27, 2015
Earlier this year Ms McCarthy compared eating meat to smoking cigarettes, telling Viva! Life magazine: “I really believe that meat should be treated in exactly the same way as tobacco, with public campaigns to stop people eating it.”
Her comments were met with ridicule; Tim Bonner of the Countryside Alliance said the idea was “cranky”, while on Twitter she was labelled an “idiot” and a “moron”.
McCarthy admitted that she was keen to avoid a similar pasting by making a sexist faux-pas on behalf of the fishing industry, commenting “I just know what Twitter is like! If I say fishermen someone will pull me up on it! If I query it, even more people will!”
Others questioned whether it was really a problem at all though, leading to McCarthy herself admitting it might not be.
That worries me as well. You got your finger on the nations pulse. @KerryMP — Mister Snoops (@Mister_Snoops) November 27, 2015
@Alichat66 no, I was just musing on it, it’s really not a big deal, is it?
— Kerry McCarthy (@KerryMP) November 27, 2015
@KerryMP Not at all. I’m not even aware, today, of any women working on trawlers, etc.
— Ali L (@Alichat66) November 27, 2015
Charles Walker, a senior Tory MP, told the Telegraph: “I am sure her statement on this matter will be met with some agricultural comments from fishermen and women.
“How such utterances advance of the English commercial fishing fleet, I don’t know. With every one of its meaningless utterances Labour is losing its mandate to be taken seriously across the country and countryside.”
COMMENTS
Please let us know if you're having issues with commenting.