As Mary Katherine Ham points out, since this is the only data we have, it’s “EVERYTHING“:

First in the nation Dixville Notch, N.H. casts five votes for Obama and five votes for Romney at midnight on Election Day. It’s the first time the tiny town has ever ended in a tie for the presidential race.

In 2008, Obama won Dixville 15-6.

The headline is a joke, by the way. People might have moved away, etc.