Vatican Hospital Chief Decries ‘Ideological’ Motives Behind Alfie Evans Ruling

(Photo - Kate James/Alfie's Army)
Kate James/Alfie's Army

The director of the Vatican-owned Bambino Gesù children’s hospital said Thursday that UK authorities are carrying on an “ideological battle” in their obstinate refusal to let little Alfie Evans be treated elsewhere, which betrays “hostility toward the Vatican hospital.”

At the behest of Pope Francis, the Vatican hospital not only offered to treat Alfie Evans, who suffers from an unknown degenerative brain disorder, but had a ambulance plane at the ready to transport him once British judges gave permission for him to leave England—which has not happened.

In an interview published Thursday in the Spanish daily ABC, Mariella Enoc, director of the Bambino Gesù, said that the decision of the UK High Court forbidding that Alfie travel elsewhere for treatment “does not strictly stem from legal reasoning” but is ideologically driven.

“This very rigid way of applying the law shows that they do not accept dialogue,” Ms. Enoc said, while expressing her displeasure at the “bitterness” of the debate over the fate of the toddler.

“In these days we have had doctors a step away from the medically equipped plane of the Ministry of Defense at the Rome’s Ciampino airport to go and get him, but they have not allowed us to do so,” she lamented. “The plane is still at our disposal in Ciampino, but I fear that everything is useless.”

Ms. Enoc flew to Liverpool, England, last Monday to offer the services of the Bambino Gesù hospital for Alfie Evans, but met with a discourteous cold shoulder, with hospital management refusing to even speak with her.

“In these moments, I feel that we must accept what we do not want to accept,” Enoc said. “There is a law that is stronger than all of us. And we have only to wait for the death of the child.”

Hospital staff are now reportedly doing everything in their power to accelerate the death of the infant, withholding oxygen and fluids from the boy.

Meanwhile, public figures ranging from Pope Francis to the president of the European Parliament to the Italian foreign and interior ministers have weighed in on behalf of Alfie and his parents, while UK authorities have simply grown more entrenched in their position.

Follow Thomas D. Williams on Twitter


Please let us know if you're having issues with commenting.