Analysis: Senate Majority May Come Down to 11 Battleground Races

Thirty-five Senate seats are up for grabs in November, but 11 of them could determine which party controls the Senate in the next Congress.

Republicans need to gain a net one seat to take back the majority in the upper chamber, which is currently split 50–50 but controlled by Democrats because the vice president casts tiebreaking votes.

Republicans’ opportunity to take over lies in seven toss-up elections and four elections that lean either toward Republican or Democrat, according to the most up-to-date RealClearPolitics map. The map shows Democrat incumbents in Georgia, Nevada, Arizona, New Hampshire, and Colorado will have to work to defend their seats, and the same goes for Republican incumbents in Wisconsin and Florida.

Up for grabs are open seats of retiring senators in North Carolina, Pennsylvania, Missouri, and Ohio.

North Carolina, Toss-up

One of the first battleground state primaries happens in North Carolina on May 17. On the Republicans’ side, one top contender is Rep. Ted Budd (R-NC), whom former President Donald Trump endorsed in a surprise announcement last June. Support from both Trump and the conservative Club for Growth, which is pouring millions into Budd’s campaign — including by launching a $10 million ad blitz in the last two months of the primary — has strengthened Budd’s winnability. The North Carolina congressman is facing former Gov. Pat McCrory (R), who previously served as Charlotte mayor and host to a popular Charlotte radio show.

McCrory is backed by the state’s retiring senator, Sen. Richard Burr (R-NC), who is leaving office on a sour note with Trump after joining six other senators in voting to convict Trump over the January 6 riot. McCrory also recently spoke out in support of Trump’s longtime nemesis Senate GOP Leader Mitch McConnell (R-KY), saying he wanted “to compliment” McConnell for his take on the concept of “legitimate political discourse.”

While Budd and McCrory were found polling neck-and-neck in a hypothetical matchup in a Cygnal poll in January, former Rep. Mark Walker (R-NC) also remains in the race in a distant third place.

The general election is therefore poised to be a matchup between either Budd or McCrory and the frontrunning Democrat candidate, Cheri Beasley, a black woman and former state Supreme Court justice who has raised the most money among the Democrat candidates so far.

Trump just barely edged out a victory in North Carolina in 2020 — winning with about 1.4 percent of the vote. That thin margin suggests the Senate race could also come down to the wire, especially if Budd, Trump’s preferred candidate, wins the primary and runs a campaign that mirrors that of the former president’s.

Pennsylvania, Toss-up

Pennsylvania Republicans have been warming up to former hedge fund CEO David McCormick as a top Senate contender after Trump-backed candidate Sean Parnell’s campaign was derailed by a public custody battle with his estranged wife. In at least three recent polls, McCormick has led the second-place candidate, television celebrity Dr. Mehmet Oz, by a modest margin in the race to replace retiring Sen. Pat Toomey (R-PA).

Although Oz carries a hundred percent name recognition and initially appeared well-received when he launched his campaign, his background has been scrutinized amid his bid for office and unearthed concerns seem to be tarnishing his candidacy. Oz at one point, for instance, appeared to promote “red flag” gun control laws on one of his shows, was found to have ownership in a company fined for employing illegal aliens, and has raised questions about his deep roots in Turkey, where he has dual-citizenship.

Also in the primary mix are military veteran Kathy Barnette, real estate developer Jeff Bartos, and businesswoman Carla Sands. The latest primary poll, taken by Fox News, showed all three polling in the single digits behind McCormick and Oz, though a plurality of respondents in that poll, or 31 percent, said they were undecided on whom to vote for.

The Republican candidate is likely to face Lt. Gov. John Fetterman (D) or Rep. Conor Lamb (D-PA) in the general election. A Philadelphia Inquirer report recently described the Democrat contest as a “Pennsylvania-sized version of Joe Biden vs. Bernie Sanders,” in which Lamb has attempted a more moderate persona while Fetterman appears more outside the box.

The primary takes place in two months on May 17, the same day as North Carolina’s.

Georgia, Toss-up

Georgia’s general election for Senate, which will take off after the state’s May 24 primary, has shaped into a likely faceoff between incumbent Sen. Raphael Warnock (D-GA) and former athlete Herschel Walker. Walker, who is a household name in Georgia after winning the Heisman Trophy as a University of Georgia football star and going on to play in the NFL, has been polling miles ahead of his closest primary challenger, Agriculture Commissioner Gary Black.

Walker represents a rare case of being backed by both Trump and Trump foe McConnell and has promoted a vision for a unified Republican Party amid other primary battles in his state — most notably the gubernatorial race between Gov. Brian Kemp (R) and former Sen. David Perdue (R-GA) — being bitter and combative in nature.

When McConnell, who has typically backed incumbents, announced his endorsement of Walker, Walker thanked him for “his commitment to bringing the party together toward the collective goal of defeating Senator Warnock.”

Made a quick trip to DC to see some friends and future colleagues. We talked about how we have to save the American Dream so that everyone can have the opportunity to succeed. We are so grateful to have you all on @teamherschel! 🇺🇸 pic.twitter.com/RLPX4iV8L0

— Herschel Walker (@HerschelWalker) March 11, 2022

Georgia has evolved into one of the most contentious battleground states. While the state has had a fully Republican-controlled legislature for almost two decades, Democrats stunned the country in 2020 by eking out narrow wins in Georgia at the federal level. The presidential race there was the closest of any state and came down to about 12,000 votes out of nearly five million votes cast.

Warnock, a longtime pastor, also won in that election cycle and is now finishing out the late Sen. Johnny Isakson’s term. Indicative of Georgia’s highly competitive political landscape is the fact that Warnock and Walker both ended 2021 as two of the top Senate fundraisers in the country. Warnock was, however, number one nationwide in the last quarter, amassing $9.8 million and reporting a monster sum of $23 million in cash on hand.

Walker has nevertheless been edging out Warnock in polls, but the race is angling to be a tight one considering Walker’s lead has stayed within the polls’ margins of error.

Nevada, Toss-up

Sen. Catherine Cortez Masto (D-NV) appears to be one of Democrats’ most vulnerable incumbents heading into the midterms. She will likely face Trump-backed Adam Laxalt, who formerly served as the state’s attorney general. One indicator of Masto’s vulnerability lies in a recent Wall Street Journal poll that found Republicans lead Democrats by nine points with Hispanic voters. The New York Times detailed that Masto began her campaign strategy in 2022 in part by targeting Nevada’s Hispanic population, which makes up a little under a third of the state’s total population. The clear gains Republicans have made with that voting bloc serve to endanger Masto’s reelection chances considering she appears to be planning to rely on Hispanic voters.

The state’s primary takes place June 14, and polling has so far shown mixed results for both Laxalt and Masto in a hypothetical general matchup.

Arizona, Toss-up

Second only to Warnock in fundraising in the last quarter of 2021 was incumbent Sen. Mark Kelly (D-AZ), a former astronaut who banked $8.9 million according to his last financial report. The Republican who will undertake challenging the well-funded Arizona Democrat is somewhat unclear in the early stages of the primary, which takes place August 2, but election integrity is likely to be a top topic for candidates.

After 2020, concerns over the election results dominated headlines in Arizona, and Trump has since found himself at odds with state leaders as he continues to contest the results, which showed he lost by less than half a percent. One such leader, Gov. Doug Ducey (R), whom the New York Times detailed as McConnell’s preferred candidate, recently ruled out running.

Attorney General Mark Brnovich (R), who is running, won a high-profile U.S. Supreme Court case last year upholding a ban on ballot harvesting, but Brnovich has still come under pressure from Trump for not doing more to pursue Trump’s claims of election fraud in Maricopa County. Billionaire entrepreneur Peter Thiel is throwing his weight behind Brnovich challenger Blake Masters, a venture capitalist and president of Thiel’s eponymous foundation.

Wisconsin, Toss-up

Sen. Ron Johnson (R-MO) is pursuing reelection in Wisconsin with the backing of Trump. Democrats have until the August 9 primary to determine the candidate best equipped to unseat Johnson, and there are many to choose from at this stage. Lt. Gov. Mandela Barnes (D) currently stands out as a frontrunner as he is leading in polls and boasts endorsements from prominent Sens. Cory Booker (D-NJ) and Elizabeth Warren (D-MA).

While Trump lost Wisconsin in 2020 by less than one point, advantageous to Johnson are Biden’s national approval, which has been deeply underwater for months, along with Gov. Tony Evers’ (D) baggage from Kenosha riots in 2020 and a horrific parade massacre in Waukesha this year allegedly carried out by a man with a long criminal track record. Evers is also up for reelection and considered one of the most vulnerable governors in the midterms.

New Hampshire, Toss-up

The primary in the Granite State is still six months away, slated for September 13, and Sen. Maggie Hassan (D-NH) has yet to see a clear Republican opponent emerge. The best-known potential challenger, Gov. Chris Sununu (R), decided at the end of last year to instead run for reelection as governor, despite encouragement from McConnell and other national Republicans like Sen. Ted Cruz (R-TX), according to a Fox News report.

Republican candidates at this stage include Army veteran Donald Bolduc, who served multiple tours in Afghanistan and ran for Senate in 2020, state Sen. Chuck Morse, and Londonderry Town Manager Kevin Smith.

The GOP has targeted Hassan’s seat as a pickup opportunity that is especially ripe given Hassan won her race in 2016 by the narrowest Senate race margin in the country, 0.1 percent, or about 1,000 votes.

Missouri, Lean Republican

Former Gov. Eric Greitens (R), a retired Navy SEAL, has been leading in Republican primary polls ahead of the August 2 primary race. The Missouri Republican is an outspoken ally of Trump and reinforced his allegiance to the president last fall when he declared in a Breitbart News op-ed that he would not support McConnell as Senate GOP leader should Greitens be elected. Candidates trailing Greitens have pointed to scandals that plagued his tenure as governor, including a sexual assault charge that was ultimately dropped in court but still prompted him to resign from office in 2018 because of what he described as an “incredible amount of strain” on his family.

The primary field is packed with other Republicans, including Rep. Vicky Hartzler (R-MO), whom Sen. Josh Hawley (R-MO) is supporting; Attorney General Eric Schmitt, whom Cruz is supporting; Rep. Billy Long (R-MO); and Mark McCloskey, who famously appeared with his wife as armed homeowners amid Black Lives Matter protests and riots.

The winner of the GOP primary appears to be headed for a race against Marine veteran Lucas Kunce or former state Sen. Scott Sifton, the two best-funded candidates in the Democrat primary.

While RealClearPolitics rates the general election here as “lean Republican,” Cook Political Report, another election analysis outlet, rates it “solid Republican.”

Florida, Lean Republican

Incumbent Sen. Marco Rubio (R-FL) has so far been outraised by his likely Democrat challenger, Rep. Val Demings (D-FL), who reported the third-highest Senate fundraising haul behind Warnock and Kelly last quarter. Rubio has however continued to dominate the race in polls. Once a presidential contender and target of Trump’s mockery in 2016, Rubio now finds himself endorsed by Trump in his bid for a third term in office.

Benefitting Rubio is Florida’s reddening trajectory. The Sunshine State, led by Gov. Ron DeSantis (R), became a mandate-free respite in the face of nationwide Democrat-led coronavirus mandates over the past two years, and now, for the first time in history, Republicans have surpassed Democrats in voter registration.

Ohio, Lean Republican

The latest polling here has businessman Mike Gibbons out in front in the GOP primary for this open seat, with former state Treasurer Josh Mandel in second place and author J.D. Vance either tied for second or in third place. Former Ohio GOP chairwoman Jane Timken and state Sen. Matt Dolan — two establishment forces — are also in the hunt but down in fourth and fifth place in polling. Whoever wins the primary will likely face Rep. Tim Ryan (D-OH) in the general election to succeed retiring Sen. Rob Portman (R-OH).

Trump won this state by wide margins in both 2016 and 2020, and the reddened nature of Ohio bodes well for whoever wins the GOP nomination. However, the Buckeye State is still a battleground state and Democrats seek to take this one if they can in November.

Colorado, Lean Democrat

Sen. Michael Bennet (D-CO) could face any of a handful of Republican candidates running in the June 28 primary, including Olympian and former local GOP chair Eli Bremer, businessman Joe O’Dea, real estate developer Gino Campana, state Rep. Ron Hanks, or radio host Deborah Flora.

Colorado is a tough state for Republicans to win in statewide in any cycle, but they have done it before in recent history as now former Sen. Cory Gardner (R-CO) showed. If 2022 ends up being a big red wave year, this one could swing towards the GOP in the home stretch, but do not expect it to be easy as Bennet is likely to have the backing of significant national Democrat forces and finances.

Disclosure: Breitbart News is represented by Cooper & Kirk, PLLC. Adam Laxalt is a partner at Cooper & Kirk. He is not actively engaged or working on any matters for Breitbart News.

Write to Ashley Oliver at aoliver@breitbart.com. Follow her on Twitter at @asholiver.